‘Exceptional X-men’ Review: Kate Pryde Solves Trauma by Accidentally Starting an X-Team

It is no secret that we love X-Men around here. We read basically all of them, which during the From the Ashes era occasionally felt less like a hobby and more like Marvel had assigned us homework. But Exceptional X-Men immediately stood out because it was not trying to be another giant mutant mission or another book about rebuilding the X-Men as an institution. Instead, Kate Pryde wants absolutely nothing to do with any of that, which obviously means she accidentally ends up responsible for a bunch of teenage mutants. Perfect.

Exceptional X-men #1

Exceptional X-Men

Publisher: Marvel Comics
Writer: Eve L. Ewing
Artists: Carmen Carnero, Federica Mancin
Colorist: Nolan Woodard
Letterer: Travis Lanham
Main Cover Artist: Carmen Carnero
Issues: #1–13
Release Dates: September 2024 – September 2025

Kate Pryde Would Like One Normal Job, Please

After everything that happened during the fall of Krakoa, Kate is exhausted. She spent part of that era as Shadowkat doing some extremely violent things, and when Exceptional X-Men begins, she is trying to get as far away from the X-Men as possible. She is bartending in Chicago. She wants a normal life. No mutant politics, no teams, and definitely no children whose survival suddenly becomes her responsibility.

Obviously, that lasts about five minutes.

What I liked immediately is that Kate does not avoid leadership because she stopped caring. She avoids it because she cares and no longer trusts herself to be the person these kids need. That makes Bronze, Axo, and Melee showing up in her life at exactly this moment wonderfully inconvenient.

Emma Frost Has Entered the Chat

And then there is Emma. Kate and Emma together will always work for me. Their relationship has gone through so many stages that at this point they can communicate entire arguments through one facial expression and three words of passive aggression. They have history, they respect each other, they annoy the hell out of each other, and they understand parts of one another that most characters never will, which makes putting them together as reluctant mentors such an easy win.

Eve L. Ewing gets that dynamic without turning the book into nonstop nostalgia for older X-Men stories. Their history matters, but Exceptional X-Men still belongs to this particular moment in their lives. Kate is trying to run from who she became, while Emma is still Emma Frost and therefore deals with most emotional problems by being correct at people until they surrender. Healthy? Debatable. Entertaining? Absolutely.

Bronze, Axo, and Melee Are the Actual Heart of the Book

As much as I came into this for Kate and Emma, the new mutants are what made the series work. Bronze, Axo, and Melee still have that slightly terrifying optimism young X-Men get before they have personally lived through approximately five mutant genocides, and watching them discover their abilities, screw things up, build friendships, and slowly figure out what being part of this world means gives Exceptional X-Men a completely different energy from most of the other From the Ashes books.

They also do not feel like three interchangeable students waiting for veteran X-Men to teach them life lessons. Each one has enough personality and their own problems that I genuinely started caring about where they were headed. Axo’s storyline becomes especially important as the series goes on, eventually pulling the team toward Sheldon Xenos and, because apparently these children had not suffered enough yet, Mister Sinister. You know, standard school extracurriculars.

This Is More About Becoming an X-Man Than Being One

The thing I appreciated most about Exceptional X-Men is that it understands being an X-Man should mean something beyond putting on a costume and punching whichever anti-mutant organization has rebranded itself this week. Kate is terrified of becoming responsible for these kids because she knows what being an X-Man can cost, while the kids are looking at her and Emma as people who survived all of that and somehow kept going.

That tension gives the book its emotional center. Kate thinks her past disqualifies her from teaching them, but the kids slowly prove that her past might actually be exactly why she understands what they need. And yes, I am a sucker for the experienced character who insists they are absolutely not becoming a mentor approximately ten minutes before becoming everyone’s emotional support adult.

Carmen Carnero Was Perfect for This

Carmen Carnero’s character work is probably my favorite part of the visuals. She is so good at faces, especially when Emma is silently judging someone, Kate is pretending she is fine, or one of the kids realizes they may have made an extremely poor decision. The action looks great, but it is those smaller expressions that really sell the relationships.

Federica Mancin comes in for the later issues and the transition works surprisingly well. The art stays expressive and character-focused right through the end, which matters for a series where the conversations are often just as important as whatever mutant disaster is happening around them. Nolan Woodard’s colors keep the whole book visually cohesive too, so the change never feels disruptive.

I Wish This One Had More Time

Thirteen issues is not nothing, but by the end I still wanted more. Bronze, Axo, and Melee all felt like characters with a lot more room to grow, and Kate and Emma mentoring young mutants is a setup I could happily read for another twenty issues without complaining. Okay, I would probably complain about something. I am an X-Men fan. That is part of the contract.

But Exceptional X-Men gave the From the Ashes era something important: a smaller, character-driven book about what comes after everything falls apart. Kate does not heal because someone gives her one inspirational speech about moving forward. She heals because three young mutants need her, Emma refuses to let her disappear completely, and eventually Kate has to accept that being damaged does not mean she has nothing left to give.

The complete series is now available across two collected volumes, with Volume 1 collecting Issues #1–5 and Volume 2 collecting #6–13. And if Marvel ever wants to put Kate and Emma in charge of another mutant school together, I will be there immediately. Those children will need therapy, and frankly, so will the teachers.

Related Reading

If Kate Pryde trying to rebuild herself after mutant disaster is your thing, our Rogue (2026) review also focuses on an X-Man whose history continues to follow her even after years of growth. And for another very different X-Men story built around a powerful woman figuring out who she is outside the usual team structure, our Rogue: The Savage Land review gives Anna Marie dinosaurs, Magneto, and considerably fewer clothes.

FAQ

What is Exceptional X-Men about?
After the fall of Krakoa, Kate Pryde tries to leave the X-Men behind but ends up mentoring three young mutants, Bronze, Axo, and Melee, alongside Emma Frost.

Who created Exceptional X-Men?
Eve L. Ewing writes the series, with art by Carmen Carnero and Federica Mancin, colors by Nolan Woodard, and lettering by Travis Lanham.

How many issues is Exceptional X-Men?
The series ran for 13 issues from September 2024 through September 2025.

Is Exceptional X-Men collected?
Yes. Volume 1 collects Issues #1–5, while Volume 2 collects Issues #6–13, so the complete series is available in two trades.

Do you need to read the Krakoa era before Exceptional X-Men?
No, but knowing what Kate went through during the fall of Krakoa adds extra weight to why she is so reluctant to become an X-Man or mentor again.