Our Top 12 Picks for Comic Series Debuting in September 2025

Written by:

September is stacked with great new comics! There’s a big wave of indie horror and thrillers this month alongside some massive superhero launches from DC and Marvel, making this one of the most varied and exciting lineups of the year.

Batman – DC Comics
The story: Matt Fraction and Jorge Jiménez team up to launch a bold new era for Gotham’s Dark Knight, with Bruce Wayne facing challenges that will test him like never before.
Why we’re intrigued: We’re not the biggest Batman fans, but Matt Fraction kicking off a new run is reason enough to check in.

Battleworld – Marvel Comics
The story: The world from Secret Wars returns, pitting heroes from across the Multiverse against one another on a patchwork planet with Maestro at the center.
Why we’re intrigued: The Battleworld concept is a classic, and we’re curious to see how Marvel updates it!

Black Diamond – PANICK Entertainment
The story: On a family ski trip, a couple’s son is kidnapped by a cult that demands they find another child to sacrifice or lose their own.
Why we’re intrigued: Cults, difficult choices, and a haunting setting are the kind of ingredients we can’t resist. Read more about it here!

Creepshow – Image Comics
The story: The cult horror anthology is back with chilling new tales, including inheritance gone wrong and a writer who really should have stayed out of that one little house.
Why we’re intrigued: Big Creepshow fans here, and with Fall and Halloween around the corner, the timing is perfect.

Everything Dead & Dying – Image Comics
The story: The last man standing after a zombie apocalypse has chosen to live peacefully with the undead, including his husband and daughter, until outsiders threaten to destroy it all.
Why we’re intrigued: A tender yet terrifying take on zombies, queer family dynamics, and a farming town setting? This is our kind of slow-burn horror. Read more about it here!

Flow – Mad Cave Studios
The story: A girl cruelly bullied at summer camp over her first period grows up to be the suspected source of a deadly curse that has come back to torment her abusers.
Why we’re intrigued: A feminist horror with blood, shame, and vengeance? We are so in. Read more about it here!

Gray Lady – Image Comics
The story: A grieving mother receives a psychic warning that her lost son is in danger, pulling her into a chilling supernatural mystery.
Why we’re intrigued: We love supernatural thrillers, and this mix of grief, hope, and terror feels like it could hit hard.

It Killed Everyone But Me – Mad Cave Studios
The story: Decades after surviving a brutal teen massacre, Sutton Reed is forced to revisit her past when new killings strike her hometown.
Why we’re intrigued: Blood, trauma, mystery, and revenge with a slasher twist… Yes, it’s exactly our kind of horror ride. Read more about it here!

Marvel Zombies: Red Band – Marvel Comics
The story: The Marvel Universe’s most famous origin story is reimagined with heroes returning not just changed, but hungry for flesh.
Why we’re intrigued: We love Marvel Zombies, and the promise of a red band series has us thrilled.

Murder Podcast – Ignition Press
The story: A defunct true crime podcast mysteriously starts dropping new episodes that drive listeners to kill, drawing a group of friends into a spiraling nightmare.
Why we’re intrigued: Creepy, meta, and a fresh spin on the true crime obsession? Yes, please!

Spider-Man ’94 – Marvel Comics
The story: Peter Parker swings back into action in a continuation of the beloved ’90s animated series, with fan-favorite villains making their first appearance in this world.
Why we’re intrigued: Classic Spidey nostalgia, and we’re always in for that.

Voyeur – Ignition Press
The story: A resort head of security spies on every guest through cameras, until a woman not only catches him but wants in on his real secret: a planned art heist.
Why we’re intrigued: A creepy surveillance thriller with a seductive twist sounds way too fun to pass up. And it’s written by Leah Williams!

September’s lineup is stacked with bold debuts! Let us know if we missed one of your top picks!

Leave a comment