The Jersey Devil Rises in Let This One Be a Devil

I have always been fascinated by cryptids, especially the ones where the legend has been repeated so many times that separating history from folklore starts becoming half the fun. The Jersey Devil is absolutely one of those for me, and my first introduction to it was actually The Last Broadcast back in 1998, so naturally James Tynion IV and Steve Foxe taking that legend on immediately had my attention.

Let This One Be a Devil takes us into the Pine Barrens of New Jersey for a supernatural mystery built around one of America’s strangest local legends. And because this is Tynion, it is not simply “here is a monster, people scream.” The whole idea is digging into how stories like this are created, repeated, changed, and eventually become something people swear must be true. Honestly, this is exactly the kind of weird little historical rabbit hole I enjoy falling into.

Let This One Be A Devil #1

Let This One Be a Devil

Publisher: Dark Horse Comics
Writers: James Tynion IV, Steve Foxe
Artist: Piotr Kowalski
Colorist: Brad Simpson
Letterer: Tom Napolitano
Main Cover Artist: Gavin Fullerton
Original Release: February – June 2025

So, What’s Going On With the Jersey Devil?

The story begins in the early 1900s with Henry Naughton returning to his family’s farm in the Pine Barrens of southern New Jersey. One night, he encounters something strange stalking the woods, which sends him down a research rabbit hole surrounding the legend of Mother Leeds and the supposed birth of the Jersey Devil in 1735. That is already enough to get me.

What I like about the setup is that it is not trying to reinvent the Jersey Devil into some completely unrelated modern monster. The history and folklore are part of the actual story, with Henry digging into reports, sightings, and the mythology surrounding this thing while the world around him becomes increasingly obsessed with the idea that something really is out there.

And listen, if I lived next to the Pine Barrens and everyone started telling me there was a flying horse-goat-demon situation happening in the woods, I would simply move. Problem solved.

The TRUE WEIRD Part Is What Makes This Interesting

Let This One Be a Devil was launched as the first entry in Tynion and Tiny Onion’s TRUE WEIRD line, a series built around cryptids, unexplained events, strange history, and those stories sitting somewhere uncomfortable between fact and folklore. Dark Horse described the concept pretty perfectly: “true” does not necessarily mean “real,” while “weird” can cover everything from monsters to alien encounters and unexplained events. That distinction is probably what interests me most.

Tynion has played with this territory before in books like Blue Book and The Department of Truth, where the point is not always proving whether something happened exactly as people claim. Sometimes the more interesting question is why people believe it, how the story spreads, and what happens once enough people start treating that story as reality.

The Jersey Devil is basically perfect for that.

This Creative Team Makes a Lot of Sense

Tynion and Steve Foxe co-write the series, and that pairing already made sense before Issue #1 landed. Foxe has worked both as a writer and editor across horror and superhero books, while Tynion has spent years turning conspiracy theories, monsters, and very questionable things hiding in the woods into some of my favorite comics.

Piotr Kowalski handles the art, which is another big reason this project caught my attention. I already knew his work from Bloodborne and Where Monsters Lie, and his style fits the grimy historical horror of the Pine Barrens extremely well. Brad Simpson handles colors, Tom Napolitano letters the series, and Gavin Fullerton provides the main covers. Steve Foxe

There is something about cryptid horror that really depends on atmosphere. You need to believe that there might genuinely be something just beyond the trees, even if you never get a perfect look at it, and this is exactly the kind of creative team I would trust with that.

The Whole Story Is Available Now

The original four-issue series ran from February through June 2025, so unlike when we first wrote about it, you do not have to wait around wondering what comes next anymore. All four issues have been collected in Let This One Be a Devil Volume 1, which released October 14, 2025.

The collection runs 120 pages and gathers the complete Jersey Devil story, making it a pretty easy pickup if you would rather read the whole mystery at once.

And I still love the basic idea behind TRUE WEIRD. There are so many cryptids, local legends, bizarre sightings, and unexplained pieces of history that could work in this format, especially when the goal is not simply turning every story into another monster fight. Sometimes the weirdest part is figuring out why people believed the story in the first place.

Related Reading

If the strange-history side of Let This One Be a Devil is what grabs you, our The Deviant review is another James Tynion IV story built around digging into the past and questioning what people think they know. And if you want more of Tynion leaning fully into atmospheric horror, our Spectregraph review trades cryptids for a haunted coastal mansion, but has that same slow-burn feeling that something much stranger is hiding underneath the surface.

FAQ

What is Let This One Be a Devil about?
The series follows scholar Henry Naughton in the early 1900s as an encounter in the New Jersey Pine Barrens leads him into the history and legend of the Jersey Devil.

Who created Let This One Be a Devil?
James Tynion IV and Steve Foxe write the series, with art by Piotr Kowalski, colors by Brad Simpson, lettering by Tom Napolitano, and main covers by Gavin Fullerton.

How many issues is Let This One Be a Devil?
It is a four-issue limited series that originally ran from February through June 2025.

What is TRUE WEIRD?
TRUE WEIRD is Tynion and Tiny Onion’s line exploring cryptids, strange history, unexplained events, and stories that sit somewhere between folklore and reality. Let This One Be a Devil was the first series under that banner. Dark Horse

Is Let This One Be a Devil collected?
Yes. Let This One Be a Devil Volume 1 collects Issues #1–4 and was released in October 2025.